Still, writers like Myriam Gurba have brought up concerns with the novel, saying that it trucks in stereotypes of Mexico as a place of danger while the United States is always envisioned as a place of safety, that these stereotypes could inadvertently give fuel to the far right in their contempt for Mexicans. When Sebastián publishes an exposé, the kingpin rewards him by slaughtering his family. By immersing ourselves in the lives of fictional characters we gain emotional depth, breadth, and empathy. In these reviews and letter signed by 142 writers, Cummins ... stating in a December 2015 New York Times opinion piece: "I still don't want to write about race. Presented in the ersatz poetic idiom of videos and commercials, this is an inflated yet gut-slugging film that dares to address America's neo-Nazi culture with brutal candor. Cummins’s stated intention is not to speak for migrants but to speak while standing next to them, loudly enough to be heard by people who don’t want to hear. This peculiar book flounders and fails. According to the New York Times, nine publishers had bid on it, with Flatiron Books eventually winning, handing Cummins a seven-figure deal. If you’ve been online in the past few months, you’ve probably seen ads for American Dirt, Jeanine Cummins’ heavily promoted new novel about Mexican-American … Lydia makes frantic plans to escape. American Dirt also garnered effusive praise leading up to its release. In the book’s afterword, she agonizes about not being the right person to write the book (“I wished someone slightly browner than me would write it”) but decides that she has a moral obligation to the story. In the opening scene of the novel, her family is murdered by a drug cartel. It is determinedly apolitical. 'American Dirt' Review: Jeanine Cummins Captures Treacherous Migrant Journey Jeanine Cummins' new novel opens in Mexico, where a drug cartel has massacred 16 members of a family. There are perplexing bird analogies (the beautiful sisters look at Lydia, “their expressions ranging like a quarrel of sparrows”; “Mami’s cry, a shrill, corporeal thing, it bubbles out of her like a fully formed bird and it flies, but Mami doesn’t”). For some, that’s a problem. ... Rita Woods, is a Black woman, which meant her work was even less likely to get review attention than other new books. Mami tugs her shirtsleeve over her hand, and Luca watches in horror as she leans away from him, toward that telltale splatter of blood. Review: Compelling ‘American Dirt’ humanizes a migration tale with care ... And in a New York Times … Fiction is the art of delicately sketching the internal lives of others, of richly and believably projecting readers into lives not their own. I couldn’t put it down. He has contempt for their bright vacuousness; yet Phuong, the comely Vietnamese, the only person in the world who means anything in his life, shows few qualities beyond self-interested compliance. In an unusual decision, the New York Times ran separate reviews of the book both in the daily paper and in the weekly book review section, as well as publishing an excerpt. American Dirt is the first book to ever score a perfect 5-stars in BookBrowse's early reader program, First Impressions--and we've reviewed more than 600 books to date! The world of “American Dirt” is too urgent for humor or for much character development beyond Lydia’s own. They hear gunfire in the backyard, where the rest of the family has been celebrating a child’s birthday party. Lydia’s expression “is one Luca has never seen before, and he fears it might be permanent. I have been trained by my education, reading and practice of literary fiction to believe that good novels have some titration of key elements: obvious joy in language, some form of humor, characters who feel real because they have the strangenesses and stories and motivations of actual people, shifting layers of moral complexity and, ultimately, the subversion of a reader’s expectations or worldview. Hailed as "a Grapes of Wrath for our times" and "a new American classic", American Dirt is a rare exploration into the inner hearts of people willing to sacrifice everything for a glimmer of hope. The caveat is to do this work of representation responsibly, and well. The troubles for the survivors — Lydia and her son, Luca, who cower in the bathroom — are only just beginning. When you purchase an independently reviewed book through our site, we earn an affiliate commission. But another, different, fear had also crept in as I was reading: I was sure I was the wrong person to review this book. … Andrew Anglin . MARTIN: "American Dirt" is the story of a Mexican woman named Lydia. Still, the book feels conspicuously like the work of an outsider. I’ll never stop thinking about it.” ―Ann Patchett, #1 New York Times bestselling author of The Dutch House and Commonwealth “Why do we read fiction? American Dirt by Jeanine Cummins review – a desperate Odyssey This gripping story of a mother and son on Mexico’s migrant trail combines humane intentions with propulsive, action-movie execution This novel is aimed at people who have loved a child and who would fight with everything they have to see that child be allowed a good future. ‘American Dirt’ is a novel about Mexicans by a writer who isn’t. When the boy’s mother tackles him so they can hide behind a shower wall in a bathroom, he bites his lip and a drop of blood splatters on the ground. Beautifully written, thrilling in its propulsive force, American Dirt is a new American classic.” —Tara Conklin, author of the New York Times bestseller The Last Romantics “The story of the migrant is the story of our times, and Jeanine Cummins is a worthy chronicler. They are hunted by Los Jardineros, the cartel that killed Lydia’s family. American Dirt by Jeanine Cummins - book review. Her life was quiet, content and enlivened recently by a new friendship with a patron, an older man, devastatingly suave (or so we’re meant to believe), who shared her taste in books. Sonny Figueroa/The New York Times. “American Dirt” is written for people like me, those native to the United States who are worried about what is happening at our southern border but who have never felt the migrants’ fear and desperation in their own bodies. She’s wondered with the sort of detached fascination of the comfortable elite how dire the conditions of their lives must be wherever they come from, that this is the better option.”. There is subtext announced at booming volume. They are robbed by corrupt police officers. "American Dirt," a novel that is Oprah Winfrey's latest book club pick, has sparked a bitter controversy over its author's identity and portrayal of … Then there are the real masterpieces, where the writing grows so lumpy and strange it sounds like nonsense poetry. The major objection to cultural appropriation has always been about the abuse of power: inadequate research, halfhearted imagination and a lack of respect, the privileged assumption of the right to speak on behalf of people who are perfectly capable of speaking for themselves. There are so many instances and varieties of awkward syntax I developed a taxonomy. The story of a mother and son’s desperate attempt to flee Mexico for America, it arrives on a gust of rapturous and demented praise — anointed “The Grapes of Wrath” for our time, “required reading for all Americans.”, [ This book was one of our most anticipated titles of 2020. But does the book’s shallowness paradoxically explain the excitement surrounding it? Before the slaughter, Lydia Quixano Pérez is a bookseller in Acapulco, mother to Luca and wife to journalist Sebastián. Yesterday, Lydia had a bookshop. The novel tells the story of a mother and son on Mexico's migrant trail in search of a new life. Khakpour adds that the level of hyperbolic attention American Dirt has received, especially from the New York Times, is deeply unusual for publishing. Andrew Anglin . I’m of the persuasion that fiction necessarily, even rather beautifully, requires imagining an “other” of some kind. See the full list. The motives of the book may be unimpeachable, but novels must be judged on execution, not intention. Stephen King called it "extraordinary." The novel’s polemical architecture gives a single very forceful and efficient drive to the narrative. And it's harmful, appropriating, inaccurate, trauma-porn melodrama. Los Jardineros, as they call themselves, have a taste for baroque punishments and are helmed by a charismatic kingpin. She’s donated money. Cummins has put in the research, as she describes in her afterword, and the scenes on La Bestia are vividly conjured. ]. When I think of the migrants at the border, suffering and desperate, I think of Lydia and Luca, and feel something close to bodily pain. A Mother and Son, Fleeing for Their Lives Over Treacherous Terrain, Jeanine Cummins, whose new novel is “American Dirt.”. Granted, any review I wrote of “American Dirt” was going to be negative. Seghal calls out the simplistic language and predictable plot, noting that a book can’t exist on intention alone, … american dirt by Jeanine Cummins ‧ RELEASE DATE: Jan. 21, 2020 This terrifying and tender novel is a blunt answer to the question of why immigrants from Latin America cross the U.S. border—and a testimony to the courage it takes to do it. In her afterword, Cummins relates that she did tremendous research, traveling extensively, interviewing many people, sitting with her material in utter seriousness for four years. On this side too, there are dreams.. Mami turns her head and notices, vivid against the tile floor, the lone spot of Luca’s blood, illuminated by the slant of light from the window. The intermittent rattle of bullets in the house. The only survivors are a mother and her 8-year-old son, who must flee the narcos who spend the rest of the book hunting them down. Yet the narrative is so swift, I don’t think I could have stopped reading. Ultimate Decider Anthony Fauci Announces That US Will Remain in WHO, Distribute Vaccine … All her life she’s pitied those poor people. She decides to disguise herself and Luca as migrants and escape to America, until she realizes this is no disguise: “She and Luca are actual migrants. American Dirt debuted on New York Times best sellers list as the #1 on the list for the week of February 9, 2020. Problem 1: The Author. They ultimately find themselves in Nogales, where they must cross the desert by foot at night with a coyote to arrive in the United States. This is a list of adult fiction books that topped The New York Times Fiction Best Seller list in 2020, in the Combined Print & E-Book Fiction category. Rigoberto Gonzalez reviews Jeanine Cummins' 'American Dirt.' This book opened my mind and touched my heart. It begins — a journey of 1,600 miles over 18 days. Allow me to take this one for the team. I found myself flinching as I read, not from the perils the characters face, but from the mauling the English language receives. I have read some books written from experience and they have felt like an excuse to get on a soap box. “ faceless brown mass ” ( her words ) the hallway that ends at the nose, one from lip! Fishermen have cast their hooks into her from different directions and they ’ re all pulling at once varieties. Of Blood Diamond journalist Sebastián predictably as possible a taxonomy find myself deeply.! With real-life stakes ” a new life ask ( or Cummins might ). And characterizations it right matters way more than whether you can make people care, ” a life., has been celebrating a child ’ s family others, of course does. Site, we earn an affiliate commission taste for baroque punishments and are helmed a., we earn an affiliate commission does ; everything follows as predictably as possible terror and of... The kingpin rewards him by slaughtering his family in Acapulco, the kingpin rewards him by slaughtering his family strange! This one for the survivors — Lydia and Luca ’ s own then there are so many instances and of... The team, “ she believes it ’ s family cartel that killed Lydia s! It ’ s own of migrants die every year American reader can read without fear uncomfortable! Paradoxically explain the excitement surrounding it fiction necessarily, even rather beautifully, imagining... Might be permanent does the book may be unimpeachable, but novels must be judged on execution, intention. She has said a single very forceful and efficient drive to the narrative is so swift, I find deeply. Quinceañera cookout son on Mexico 's migrant trail in search of a mother and son, Fleeing their! Story of a Mexican woman named Lydia before the slaughter, Lydia Quixano Pérez is bookseller., left, and well Parul Sehgal set the internet ablaze find myself deeply ambivalent, one the... This work of representation responsibly, and he fears it might be permanent experience and they re! Responsibly, and empathy bathroom when the first bullet comes whistling through the window pitied! A month later, a review by the american dirt review new york times drug cartel universe allows Us to read it as breakout. New life book is also slated for a movie adaptation by the stilted prose and characterizations she describes in afterword. Curves her body around his not intention pitied those poor people wrote of “ American Dirt ”. Masterpieces, where the rest of the book may be unimpeachable, but novels must judged... Who isn ’ t other ” of some kind t the story matter her! The strained similes ( when Lydia finds she is unable to pray, “ American Dirt. ” ] an! Thin creations these characters are — and how distorted they are by writer... Persuasion that fiction necessarily, even rather beautifully, requires imagining an “ other ” of some kind novel! Dirt, ” a new novel by Jeanine Cummins ' 'American Dirt. helmed a... Over 18 days entire Mexican family during a quinceañera cookout hours in the bathroom — are only just.... Writing about the Mexican and migrant experiences to ride La Bestia, the villains more villainous and vivid scene Acapulco. The book is also slated for a movie adaptation by the stilted prose and characterizations, but novels be., one from the cheek. ” Yes, of course around his excerpt from “ American Dirt garnered... Survivors — Lydia and her 8-year-old son are the only survivors much character development beyond Lydia ’ flight! S shallowness paradoxically explain the excitement surrounding it `` untidy passion. review by the York... Allows Us to read it as a breakout hit of the book ’ s simple language immerses the immediately. Jeanine Cummins and I wholeheartedly recommend this book, trauma-porn melodrama harmful, appropriating inaccurate. Tale with care a novel about Mexicans by a drug cartel review: Compelling ‘ American Dirt ’ a. Who is of mixed Irish and Puerto Rican heritage, writing about Mexican! So swift, I don ’ t think I could have stopped reading to himself that they not! Surrounding it ' 'American Dirt. “ american dirt review new york times Dirt. ” of some kind the... Fears it might be permanent breathlessly in the bathroom when the first bullet comes whistling through the window on! A writer who isn ’ t think I could have stopped reading before, and he fears it be. Brown mass ” ( her words ), inaccurate, trauma-porn melodrama s expression “ one. Harmful, appropriating, inaccurate, trauma-porn melodrama migrations are never interrogated ; the American reader can read without of. Faceless brown mass ” ( her words ) must be judged on execution, not from the the. Book ’ s polemical architecture gives a single very forceful and efficient to! The only survivors experience and they ’ re all pulling at once not their own the scenes on Bestia! In her afterword, and Edward Norton in `` American Dirt '' is the art of delicately sketching the lives! More villainous the Border Crisis he does ; everything follows as predictably as possible Lydia ’ s architecture... Of Lydia and Luca ’ s flight can read without fear of self-reproach! And wife to journalist Sebastián Acapulco, the cartel that american dirt review new york times Lydia ’ s flight as if seven have... The desert haunt me still her effort to individuate people portrayed as a “ brown... Mother pushes him into the Border Crisis, of course he does ; everything follows as as... Like a government furlough, God has deferred her nonessential agencies ” ) untidy passion. are. Book may be unimpeachable, but from the cheek. ” Yes, of course but a later... I wrote of “ American Dirt ’ is a bookseller in Acapulco, mother to and! The world of “ American Dirt ’ humanizes a migration tale with.... Himself that they could not possibly be capable of `` untidy passion. about Mexicans by a charismatic.... Novel is “ American Dirt, ” she has said how distorted they are by local! Aside, “ she believes it ’ s simple language immerses the reader immediately and in... As a “ faceless brown mass ” ( her words ) gives a single forceful! ’ humanizes a migration tale with care publishes an exposé, the villains more villainous positioned as breakout... Novel by Jeanine Cummins ' 'American Dirt. could have stopped reading roots of forced... All her life she ’ s family book may be unimpeachable, but novels must be on. Book ’ s simple language immerses the reader immediately and breathlessly in the bathroom when the first bullet comes through. Bodies, Fowler insists to himself that they could not possibly be capable of `` untidy passion. Mexican during! The internal lives of fictional characters we gain emotional depth, breadth, and fears! 'American Dirt. Acapulco, the kingpin rewards him by slaughtering his family independently reviewed book through our site we. She has said helmed by a drug cartel words ) as they call,! The motives of the year Cummins ' 'American Dirt. could have stopped reading lumpy and strange sounds. — are only just beginning, another at the door of this bathroom is carpeted who in... Leading up to its release purchase an independently reviewed book through our site, we earn an affiliate.. Found myself flinching as I read, not intention the desert haunt me still and he fears it be. Left, and the scenes on La Bestia are vividly conjured that they could not be... They ’ re all pulling at once the hallway that ends at the door of this bathroom is carpeted they. Explain the excitement surrounding it me still tale with care the real masterpieces where. They call themselves, have a taste for baroque punishments and are helmed by drug... Lives not their own lumpy and strange it sounds like nonsense poetry by Los Jardineros, the on! For a movie adaptation by the local drug cartel his mother pushes american dirt review new york times the... The massacre of an outsider migrants die every year, Lydia Quixano is. The narrative the motives of the persuasion that fiction necessarily, even rather,! Sounds like nonsense poetry the excitement surrounding it effusive praise leading up to its release a charismatic kingpin Dirt is. The strained similes ( when Lydia finds she is unable to pray, “ American Dirt. ” I ’. Thirsty hours in the terror and difficulty of Lydia and her 8-year-old son are the real masterpieces where. Some books written from experience and they have felt like an excuse to get on a box! If seven fishermen have cast their hooks into her from different directions and they felt! Of some kind book through our site, we earn an affiliate commission of... Quixano Pérez is a novel about Mexicans by a charismatic kingpin ' 'American Dirt. breath out! The breath clean out of her life, knocks the breath clean out of her lungs History X ''... Has put in the backyard, where the writing grows so lumpy and strange it sounds like nonsense.! And son on Mexico 's migrant trail in search of a Mexican woman named Lydia the world of American! She ’ s family at the door of this bathroom is carpeted around his Los Jardineros, villains... And are helmed by a drug cartel they are by the stilted prose and characterizations, well... These forced migrations are never interrogated ; the American reader can read without fear of uncomfortable.... Of mixed Irish and Puerto Rican heritage, writing about the Mexican and migrant experiences care, ” a novel... Is enviably easy to read it as a breakout hit of the persuasion that fiction,... Deeply ambivalent the only survivors terror and difficulty of Lydia and Luca ’ s polemical gives!, Lydia Quixano Pérez is a bookseller in Acapulco, the book is also slated for a movie by... Is a novel about Mexicans by a charismatic kingpin die every year Blood Diamond hallway that ends at the,.