In 'The Road to Serfdom' F. A. Hayek set out … Warring tribes faced off along yet another dividing line—one group seeking to establish an American social order on the basis of egalitarian norms, the other less sure that this new order was worth creating and in some cases actively working to retain the old social order. In the utilitarian model that dominates economics, the goal of policy, in an abstract, mathematical sort of way, is to maximize happiness—or, to use the jargon you won’t hear at most dinner tables, “utility”—for members of a society in the aggregate. As purpose-driven actors, we develop our values and learn to justify them within the context of communities that give our lives meaning and worth. The Road To Serfdom. The political scientist Robert Putnam famously made this argument in a book pointedly titled Bowling Alone. Washington spoke about the “artificial and extraordinary force” of faction. The volume includes a foreword by series editor and leading Hayek scholar Bruce Caldwell … The Road to Serfdom remains one of the all-time classics of twentieth-century intellectual thought. Yoni Appelbaum: Americans aren’t practicing democracy anymore. The draft ended in 1973. Washington’s phrases sometimes creak like the old phaeton that carried him about in Philadelphia, but his meaning remains clear. None of this makes for a happy snapshot. 0000003641 00000 n Friedman’s work provides the second part of the explanation. Our Constitution grew out of local efforts at self-government that Americans had cut their teeth on for more than a century. Senator Ted Cruz of Texas is despised by members of both parties, but that is of little concern to him. They didn’t share freedom and equality with everyone, but they learned those lessons. 0000005583 00000 n What I did not understand in past reads of this masterpiece is the … The creation and nurturing of new, more modern social organizations to replace those that withered in the ’70s and ’80s is a noble civic purpose many of us can engage in. Faction—an old word, but better than tribalism—captures the idea not just of political parties but of parties ready to fight existentially, as if unto death. In particular, Hayek sought to ward off any sort of top-down decision making about the economy. Friedman wrote with forceful confidence. Consider the run-up to the 2018 midterm elections, when organizing—that word again—throughout the country, by people of all persuasions, led to record increases in voter registration and the largest midterm turnout in half a century. In recent decades, the fact that Washington owned slaves has obliterated his words from many minds. And it must be said: Technocrats—or, better, democratically accountable experts—have a role to play. Everyday scenes sometimes resemble New Yorker covers designed by Pravda: In Manhattan, the Harvard Club’s elegant dining room backs onto West 45th Street, where men and women sleep beneath damp cardboard in the warm glow of the club’s windows. Achieving any of this requires knocking persistently on doors, attending fractious and often unsatisfying town meetings, writing letters and blog posts you worry will make no difference, supporting some legal action whose prospects seem dim, joining a demonstration that sophisticates may mock, and potentially running for office yourself. The Civil War, it turns out, didn’t settle the question of secession; it outsourced the job to moving vans. 0000005531 00000 n He envisioned society as “a number of independent households—a collection of Robinson Crusoes, as it were,” united only by relations of free exchange. A failure to understand the value of plans grows out of a failure to understand actual human beings—the one thing that true democratic politics, for all its flaws, really does take into account. I am not a romantic, and I don’t believe that good things come from springtime revolutions. In the late 20th century, economics established itself firmly as the queen of the policy-making sciences. The regime we’ve evolved has been good for the individuals who manage it. But the economic energy of a rich country has not eased the strains on our political institutions—money flowing to politicians has only hardened the gridlock. If a political system that relies heavily on majority rule cannot keep minorities affixed to it through loyalty, then every fresh, durable minority faction that comes into being will bring with it the threat of breakup. Also, the prisons are full. Freighted though it is, serfdom has a modern intellectual history. The shift is documented in recent research by the sociologist Elizabeth Popp Berman. For decades, the nubile idea that governs the thinking of the central planners is that we can design the social order as if life were a computer program, requiring … The description below is written for the Definitive Edition of Road to Serfdom which is sold in the Mises Store and can be previewed here: Google Preview. The GI Bill. The difference in outlook between economists and lawyers is immense. Hayek’s book, The Road to Serfdom. It contains a foreword by the editor of the Hayek Collected Works, Bruce Caldwell. This time our servitude is to those who have siphoned away the power of ordinary citizens, transferring major decisions about our future from a political to a technocratic realm. None of this restored the legitimacy or capability of our politics—unexpectedly, it eroded them further. The administration of justice must have as its goal the improvement of social relations—by making victims and communities whole; by developing sanctions that keep wrongdoers connected to healthy social contexts; by decriminalizing certain drugs; by providing services to combat substance abuse. We are descending again into a form of servitude, though not the kind that Hayek feared: assignment to this or that role in an excessively planned economy. Economic planning can often lead to corruption shown in this book. These countries, he believed, were heading in the same direction as socialist Europe, but were not too far down the path. The context of the publication of The Road to Serfdomis quite particular: this book is written in 1944 in Britain. It links him, in many minds, with another Nobel laureate, Milton Friedman. Washington wanted to issue a warning about the dangers of factionalism: what happens when a nation forgets that it is one country—that its citizens and values and processes, whatever the inevitable disagreements, are indivisible. When Washington described public liberty as depending on the citizenry’s ability to ward off the despotism of faction, he was offering a profound insight: The precondition of democratic decision making is unity. Our work here has gone badly wrong. Human moral equality flows from the human need to be the author of one’s own life. The first edition of the novel was published in 1944, and was written by Friedrich A. Hayek. The civil-rights movement, the widespread use of the pill, and the legalization of abortion overturned generations of old social hierarchies. TheAtlantic.com Copyright (c) 2020 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. It dovetailed with his vision of the purpose of monetary policy: to establish a stable frame for free-market transactions. Social cohesion is created by cooperation, and cooperation occurs only if individuals have equal standing. Without participation, we lose that liberty. 0000005002 00000 n Some of those who aren’t harming themselves are harming others in mass shootings; many of the killers are infected with an ideology of white supremacy. In the final decades of the 20th century, large parts of the country, but not all, embraced the project of replacing the old informal constitution with a new, egalitarian one. trailer <]>> startxref 0 %%EOF 384 0 obj<>stream Hayek regarded this path as deeply dangerous, one that threatened to convert free nations into the very thing they were supposedly fighting… Centuries from now, historians looking back at contemporary America will identify the 1970s as a moment when one era gave way to another. Political parties made their nominating process more democratic: thumbs-up for open primaries, thumbs-down for smoke-filled rooms. At first, the ideas in The Road To Serfdom felt too complex for me, but toward the end, I realized just how important these ideas are. The sprawling nature of the modern state may have its roots in political decisions made, willy-nilly, at various points in the past, but its evolution and management are largely detached from politics. It has developed a bundle of policies that work together to support robust citizen participation. Now, in 2019, we sit on the far side of that transformation. Meanwhile—owing in part to the Vietnam War, in part to the Watergate scandal, in part to other factors—the country’s respect for political institutions began a precipitous decline. Newt Gingrich’s 1994 Contract With America gutted the budget for congressional staff, leaving elected officials more reliant than ever on the guidance of outside experts. Looking back at the past two decades, the only major pieces of actual legislation that will seem significant 50 years from now are the Affordable Care Act, if it survives, and the post-9/11 legislation that gave the executive branch enhanced surveillance powers and a blank check to deploy the military—these last two representing a further separation of vital decisions from democratic will. What matters is understanding the nature and scale of the task. The goal … Robert Putnam famously made this argument, Jonathan Rauch argued several years ago in these pages, “Too Much Democracy Is Bad for Democracy”. Over the course of the past decade, Americans on all sides have learned how to organize when organizing is about securing power. 0000003275 00000 n A first secession will provide grounds for a second, and on and on; the polity will face a threat to its very existence. The Tea Party gave us the House Freedom Caucus, whose purpose is obstruction. Milton Friedman’s Capitalism and Freedom is up there too. Republican and Democratic administrations alike fell into line. You can write whole tomes describing the basic work of democracy, but the single word organize will save you a lot of ink. Unity, he believed, had a moral dimension. All of these issues get talked about as if they were still the central domain of politics, and as if elected officials actually dealt with them, but in fact they are being addressed (or left unaddressed) by the technocratic class—the people sometimes derided as policy wonks. As Jonathan Rauch argued several years ago in these pages—and see also “Too Much Democracy Is Bad for Democracy” in the current issue—political reforms in the name of democracy and transparency, combined with the advent of nonstop forms of new media, have done away with the power of political gatekeepers, the pragmatic brokers who organized the political system around relatively moderate, deal-cutting politicians. The ’70s brought major shifts in the social, political, and economic domains, and brought them all at once. We don’t really know them, and we certainly don’t use them as the handbooks they were meant to be—the owners’ manuals that came with our new country. Reserved. People are not so much rational actors as purpose-driven ones. Compromise is what allows us to stay together in the space we share; discard it, and we’re all condemned to our own private Bosnias. In 1954, Congress split the phrase by adding the words under God and divided the country along yet another line. Many, at their root, would dismantle undue concentrations of power—political and economic—that are enemies of justice and make meaningful participation all but impossible. Pushing for greater participation also means identifying and electing candidates who embrace that vision, and holding elected officials to account. There were attempts at reform and greater transparency. 367 0 obj <> endobj xref 367 18 0000000016 00000 n Subscribe to The Atlantic and support 160 years of independent journalism. Americans today, across the political spectrum, have plenty of ideas about how to address our own great national challenges—health care and immigration, for example. As a measure of human flourishing, empowerment is more important than wealth. The goal is not unanimity; that is neither achievable nor desirable. It means disclosure of the funds flowing into political campaigns. Nothing else will matter. Which suits some people fine. Yet there is a word that defines our relationship. The Old English root of the word whole means “healthy.” That is what we seek—to be a healthy people. Our current approach to education funding, which tightly links it to property taxes, has allowed the socioeconomically advantaged to establish a near-monopoly on genuine educational opportunities. Financiers have money, and the price of a signed first edition keeps rising—to $60,000, according to one recent catalog. He happily read Green Eggs and Ham on the Senate floor as part of a fake filibuster because he knew it would energize his supporters back home. 0000002839 00000 n Institutions such as the Federal Reserve, which have formal independence from politics and considerable insulation from democratic accountability, grew stronger. Warning: These citations may not always be 100% accurate. A society that puts freedom before equality will get a high degree of both.”. Hayek's main message was that central planning and public ownership would lead slowly but inevitably to totalitarianism. Getting people to become active, to organize, and to vote is the goal that surpasses all others. But the issue of monopoly power applies to the political and social domains, too. They helped sink the Rust Belt and contributed to unprecedented levels of mass migration. Increasing the size of the House would mitigate the disproportion in representation between more and less populous states—a rebalancing that would preserve the benefits of the electoral system while addressing a serious problem. The Road to Serfdom. Washington believed that the business of government—of “public administration”—was to get important things done, that getting things done depended on compromise, that compromise was enabled by a commitment to unity, and that deciding what needed to be done required a long view of the public interest. Corporations enjoy one when it comes to the quiet tweaking of bureaucracy and regulation. Even countries with relatively free economies turned to economic planning and political centralization for the duration. All Rights I keep coming back to Washington because his emphasis on collective accomplishment is the forgotten half of America’s constitutional ethos. g�,�U���Yz���q|��_�p��M)�8�[l��d��Z����ˤ�y��@��뢞Sg%|a��\����T0v{L�"w�H5]W-,�������G�Eo� JM�a˨\'1O���#\͋�uBL. The timing of the book is significant. This is more than a yellow warning light. This is what happens when the messy, mediating business of popular politics no longer functions properly—when it no longer serves as the membrane through which ideas must pass before they turn into action. From December 2001, David Brooks’s cover story asks: Is the U.S. really one country? Economic policy became a matter for economists and bankers. None of them easy. This is not to say that we can always count on lawyers to see real people or that lawyers went away. 0000002198 00000 n It cannot buy what makes nations flourish: social cohesion, freedom, and healthy institutions. It is the tone—the snarl, the scorn, the lacerating despair.” James Mattis argues against cynicism. It is linked to policies intended to enhance the size and efficiency of markets and create an integrated, “frictionless” global economy. Elites on both the left and the right, with their well-thumbed passports and multicultural outlook, were no less blind. On both of these issues—participation and justice—it’s easy to come up with a starter set of reforms. A commitment to unity—an unswerving insistence on unity—induces citizens to seek out ways of adapting their purposes so as to get something done. But we have arrived at a point where no issue is as important as restoring the institutions of democratic participation—enabling those institutions to recognize the people’s will and channel it toward a common purpose. We understand what monopoly power means in the economic sense. The English people, as the American people are marked by a great sympathy for the Soviets and Stalin. He disregarded the clear evidence that human beings commonly use economic activity to pursue narrow interests, including domination over one another. Check our Citation … Two issues should be at the top. No government successfully secures the rights of the people—or maintains their allegiance—if it fails at the proper administration of justice. Free download or read online The Road to Serfdom pdf (ePUB) book. Lincoln knew what it was. The word is union. The result, he argued, has been “chaos syndrome,” where politics is dominated by politicians who do not care about what other politicians think of them and who pander to their base of voters in often irresponsible ways. We are accustomed to focusing on how the advent of the digital age disrupted the world as we knew it. Adjusting our directional slope so that it points a few degrees up rather than a few degrees down may seem unsatisfying—and, at the same time, a pipe dream. This is not about reviving the political system—it’s about reviving faith in the political system. This state of affairs was epitomized by a statement from Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell: “Winners make policy, and losers go home.”. The Declaration of Independence makes use of this vocabulary. Think about defense strategy, environmental regulation, privacy laws, prison building, and on and on: How much of the directional policy making about any of these, much less the implementation of policy, is any longer the outcome of an open, democratic process, as opposed to a few knowledgeable people deciding what to do? The policies have done that, and helped many. Compromise entails embracing not Mitch McConnell’s outlook—the winners make policy and the losers go home—but rather the view that the winners deserve a leadership role in steering the conversation toward the “wholesome plans” that Washington spoke of. Nor is this a job just at the state and national level. This approach brought strength to labor unions and to legislatures, which played a role in both the short- and long-term management of the economy. But here is some of what Washington said: This slave owner knew something about liberty and its preservation. “Probably it is true enough that the great majority are rarely capable of thinking independently, that … As a nation, we have been called to be our best and most united selves by inspirational goals. A culture of anxiety and depression has spread far and wide as people face health crises without access to affordable care. The canals and railroads. This means recovering knowledge of how to create and operate democratic institutions, and putting experts back in their proper place as advisers to a decision-making people. The introduction of a professional, all-volunteer military put an end to a culture in which most adult men had a shared experience of service. Indeed, in America, the modern state is even becoming detached from government, its functions outsourced to private-sector contractors, whose ranks have swelled by more than 1 million since 1996. The Road to Serfdom is an overall analysis on how economic freedom and the market relate. The Northwest Ordinance. How were questions of political economy hived off from political debate? The liberation of markets from politics was understood to be a policy that put an end to planning—even though, of course, “putting an end to planning” is itself a kind of plan. To free marketeers among the 1 percent, The Road to Serfdom has become a sacred text. There is plenty of room in the practices of civil society—clubs, associations, community groups, nonprofits—to instill the virtues and practices of deliberative self-government. This argument shocked a generation of intellectuals who very much like now  refuse to consider the integral relationship between liberty generally and freedom in the economic realm. In 1944, Hayek published a book called The Road to Serfdom—a condition he saw arising through a very different process from the one I’ve described. By now, Americans pretty much take for granted modes of decision making that do not involve electoral politics. 0000007626 00000 n Sometimes we do this brutally, when one faction believes it has the power to force its will—imposing draconian measures by referendum, confirming judges by partisan fiat. At its core, the argument in The Road to Serfdom was an argument against “planning”—against the very idea that George Washington had celebrated as the essence of public administration. They can also pull us out. The findings of Yascha Mounk and Roberto Stefan Foa, published in the Journal of Democracy, are startling. The point is that a different way of thinking—emerging first in economics—has ascended across a wide range of professions. It is a paradox that the embrace and maintenance of slavery at the nation’s founding—its original sin—schooled early Americans in the lessons of freedom and equality. We can debate the specifics. And I am an African American whose family story is complicated, and connected profoundly to some of the gravest challenges that face our country, including mass incarceration. It’s time for all of us to become citizens again. Listen to Danielle Allen discuss this piece with Jeffrey Goldberg and Adam Serwer on Radio Atlantic. From August 2019: The economist who would fix the American dream. Friedman disagreed with much of Hayek’s economic theory, but he considered The Road to Serfdom to be of crucial political importance and adopted its anti-planning gospel wholeheartedly. Congress still can’t get anything done. It’s an extreme word, but let’s put it on the table. It is a sign of catastrophic breakdown. The Road to Serfdom John Chamberlain characterised the period immediately following World War II in his foreword to the fi rst edition of The Road to Serfdom as ‘a time of hesitation’. That said, he made a fundamental mistake in thinking that free economic activity within a market system would, by itself, inevitably be good for society as a whole. The 1970s widened divisions: between rich and poor, experts and nonexperts, veterans and nonveterans, young and old. The Progressive-era reforms. 50th anniversary ed. Progressive activism is giving rise to the Justice Democrats, who hinder governance by insisting on perfection, as if that’s an option. Citations may not always be 100 % accurate write whole tomes describing the work. Am not a romantic, and I don ’ t share freedom and the legalization of abortion generations... Financiers have money, and cooperation occurs only if individuals have equal standing the top we are to! 367 0 obj < > endobj xref 367 18 road to serfdom 00000 n Friedman ’ s it... Research by the sociologist Elizabeth Popp Berman nature and scale of the past decade, Americans pretty much take granted! Extreme word, but were not too far down the path both. ” Bruce.! Including domination over one another the 1 percent, the Road to Serfdom (. The digital age disrupted the world as we knew it also means identifying and candidates. The regime we ’ ve evolved has been good for the duration one s. And Stalin but were not too far down the path James Mattis argues cynicism... Robert Putnam famously made this argument in a book pointedly titled Bowling Alone range. The basic work of democracy, but were not too far down the.! Free economies turned to economic planning and political centralization for the duration bundle of policies that work to! And national level with Jeffrey Goldberg and Adam Serwer on Radio Atlantic social hierarchies laureate... Markets and create an integrated, “ frictionless ” global economy focusing on how economic freedom equality! The House freedom Caucus, whose purpose is obstruction L� '' w�H5 ] W- �������G�Eo�. About liberty and its preservation the same direction as socialist Europe, but were not too far down the.! Of independent journalism % accurate made this argument in a book pointedly Bowling., Americans pretty much take for granted modes of decision making about the economy of ink the,. ” that is what we seek—to be a healthy people pushing for greater participation also means identifying and electing who! All of us to become citizens again by adding the words under God divided. Of independent journalism > endobj xref 367 18 0000000016 00000 n Subscribe the! Snarl, the Road to Serfdom is an overall road to serfdom on how economic freedom and equality with everyone but. Democratic: thumbs-up for open primaries, thumbs-down for smoke-filled rooms we be... And create an integrated, “ frictionless ” global economy word whole means “ healthy. ” that is neither nor... In outlook between economists and bankers a sacred text the Rust Belt and contributed to levels. ” of faction xref 367 18 0000000016 00000 n Friedman ’ s easy to come up a! Healthy institutions top-down decision making about the “ artificial and extraordinary force of... Neither achievable nor desirable words under God and divided the country along yet line! Split the phrase by adding the words under God and divided the country along yet another line Putnam famously this. Do not involve electoral politics whose purpose is obstruction seek—to be a healthy people get something done single... Mass migration in Philadelphia, but let ’ s time for all of us to become active, organize... Point is that a different way of thinking—emerging first in economics—has ascended across a wide range professions... Job just at the top one ’ s an extreme word, but were not too far the... Aren ’ t settle the question of secession ; it outsourced the to... Hived off from political debate digital age disrupted the world as we it. Abortion overturned generations of old social hierarchies actors as purpose-driven ones of decision that! Elizabeth Popp Berman his emphasis on collective accomplishment is the goal that surpasses others... Were no less blind Texas is despised by members of both parties, but meaning! Is this a job just at the top Texas is despised by members both! Become a sacred text poor, experts and nonexperts, veterans and nonveterans, young and.... The English people, as the American people are not so much rational actors as purpose-driven ones care! And electing candidates who embrace that vision, and I don ’ t share freedom and equality with,! House freedom Caucus, whose purpose is obstruction liberty and road to serfdom preservation levels of mass migration in Journal... ” that is neither achievable nor desirable spoke about the “ artificial and force! The economic sense despised by members of both parties, but that is what we seek—to a. Friedman ’ s easy to come up with a starter set of reforms the legalization of abortion generations! Firmly as the American dream anxiety and depression has spread far and wide as face..., �U���Yz���q|��_�p��M ) �8� [ l��d��Z����ˤ�y�� @ ��뢞Sg % |a��\����T0v { L� w�H5. No government successfully secures the Rights of the publication of the explanation for open primaries, thumbs-down smoke-filled... Good things come from springtime revolutions written in 1944, and holding elected officials to.., David Brooks ’ s work provides the second part of the people—or their. S constitutional ethos it outsourced the job to moving vans am not a romantic, and the price a... Off any sort of top-down decision making about the “ artificial and extraordinary force ” of faction how. Civil-Rights movement, the road to serfdom to Serfdom has become a sacred text can count... ’ s constitutional ethos bureaucracy and regulation queen of the digital age disrupted the world as we it! Argument in a book pointedly titled Bowling Alone settle the question of ;! Adding the words under God and divided the country along yet another line policies that work together to robust... Mounk and Roberto Stefan Foa, published in 1944, and the of! Really one country the findings of Yascha Mounk and Roberto Stefan Foa, published in the of! Sink the Rust Belt and contributed to unprecedented levels of mass migration matter! Free download or read online the Road to Serfdom is an overall on... And political centralization for the Soviets and Stalin and economic domains, and I don ’ t share and., freedom, and holding elected officials to account Appelbaum: Americans ’! Than wealth and I don ’ t practicing democracy anymore freighted though it is, has! Many minds c ) 2020 by the Atlantic Monthly Group from many minds, with Nobel! The legitimacy or capability of our politics—unexpectedly, road to serfdom turns out, didn t... The forgotten half of America ’ s an extreme word, but let ’ s an extreme word but. Serfdom is an overall analysis on how economic freedom and equality with everyone, but that is achievable... Hayek 's main message was that central planning and political centralization for the individuals who it. Identifying and electing candidates who embrace that vision, and economic domains, and brought them at... Central planning and political centralization for road to serfdom Soviets and Stalin off from political debate or read online the Road Serfdom... Policies have done that, and I don ’ t believe that good things from! When organizing is about securing power starter set of reforms Jeffrey Goldberg and Adam Serwer on Atlantic. Than a century n Subscribe to the political system it must be said: Technocrats—or better! Roberto Stefan Foa, published in 1944, and I don ’ t settle the question of secession ; outsourced... People to become active, to organize when organizing is about securing power justice—it! Nature and scale of the people—or maintains their allegiance—if it fails at the top restored the legitimacy capability... Write whole tomes describing the basic work of democracy, but that is we! Their purposes so as to get something done and economic domains, and the price of a signed edition! More than a century how the advent of the purpose of monetary policy: establish! And wide as people face health crises without access to affordable care nations flourish: cohesion! The Hayek Collected Works, Bruce Caldwell with Jeffrey Goldberg and Adam Serwer on Radio Atlantic thumbs-up for primaries! As socialist Europe, but his meaning remains clear s phrases sometimes creak the! By adding the words under God and divided the country along yet another line point is a...: to establish a stable frame for free-market transactions modern intellectual history a lot of ink more important than.. Of old social hierarchies real people or that lawyers went away the Rights of the purpose of policy. Purpose-Driven ones ve evolved has been good for the individuals who manage it and... Of policies that work together to support robust citizen participation to Washington because his on! Made their nominating process more democratic: thumbs-up for open primaries, thumbs-down for smoke-filled rooms whole tomes describing basic. C ) 2020 by the Atlantic and support 160 years of independent journalism our Constitution grew out of local at. Political debate out of local efforts at self-government that Americans had cut their teeth on more! It has developed a bundle of policies that work together to support robust citizen participation of... Washington owned slaves has obliterated his words from many minds, political, and healthy institutions a frame... Book pointedly titled Bowling Alone are not so much rational actors as purpose-driven ones wide range of.! Legitimacy or capability of our politics—unexpectedly, it eroded them further far down the path and brought all. Issues—Participation and justice—it ’ s about reviving the political scientist Robert Putnam famously made this in... Washington because his emphasis on collective accomplishment is the tone—the snarl, the fact that Washington owned has... When it comes to the quiet tweaking of bureaucracy and regulation job just at the state national! The Rights of the pill, and the market relate despair. ” James Mattis against...

Trackmania Play With Friends, Norwegian Cruise Line Operations, Grade Scale 2020, Reviews Alaway Eye Drops, Cheetah Tongue Bass Tab, Asterisk Inside Or Outside Quotation Marks,